Published
Pardeep S. Grewal is a lawyer at Lawgical Law Corporation, called to the BC bar in 2024, and a member of the Law Society of British Columbia.
The fix: a new application that proves the working spouse’s job really sits in an eligible occupation, with restoration if you were in Canada, or judicial review in the Federal Court if the officer ignored evidence you sent.
The deadline: 15 days from notice of the refusal to start a judicial review if you are in Canada, 60 days if you are outside (IRPA s. 72). If the refusal ended your status in Canada, you have 90 days to apply for restoration.
Why a lawyer: only a lawyer can take this to the Federal Court, and the choice between court and a new application is usually made in the first week. Why a lawyer
The lawyers who review these refusals
Sundeep S. GrewalBarrister and Solicitor
Prabhpreet Kaur SanghaBarrister and Solicitor
Pardeep S. GrewalBarrister and SolicitorAbout our lawyers
Sundeep S. Grewal founded Lawgical Law Corporation and argues immigration cases at the Immigration and Refugee Board and the Federal Court of Canada.
Prabhpreet Kaur Sangha focuses on refugee claims, immigration appeals, inadmissibility, detention reviews and Federal Court cases, and has presented at Continuing Legal Education seminars and the National Immigration Conference.
Pardeep S. Grewal is an immigration and estates lawyer known for clear communication and practical strategy.
If IRCC refused your spousal open work permit because the officer was not satisfied that your spouse works in a qualifying TEER, the officer did not doubt your marriage. The officer doubted the job: either the occupation is not on IRCC’s list, or the evidence did not convince the officer that your spouse really does the work of the occupation the employer named, for example because their education looks unrelated to it. You can usually apply again with evidence built around the job’s duties, restore your status if you were in Canada, or ask the Federal Court for judicial review within 15 days (60 days if you are outside Canada).
Lawgical Law Corporation, an immigration law firm in Surrey, Abbotsford and Vancouver, BC, reviews spousal open work permit refusals, rebuilds applications and challenges refusals in the Federal Court for families across Canada; this guide is by Pardeep S. Grewal.
Leave your details and our team will contact you to arrange a time with a lawyer. Or call (778) 598-3785.
Thank you, we have your request
A member of our team will contact you to arrange a time. If your matter is urgent, call us at (778) 598-3785, Monday to Friday, 9:00 am – 5:00 pm.
What does a “qualifying TEER” refusal say?
Spousal open work permits for the partners of foreign workers are issued under section 205(c)(ii) of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations (exemption code C41). The refusal is short. The ground usually reads like this:
- “The applicant does not qualify under the IMP as they provided insufficient information to demonstrate their spouse’s employment in a qualifying TEER. Refused under R205(c)(ii).”
A second version names the problem more directly: the officer says the working spouse’s education does not meet the requirements of the occupation (the NOC) the employer listed, so the officer is not satisfied the job is really in that occupation.
Many of these letters add a second ground: the officer is not satisfied you have enough money for your stay, or that you will leave Canada at the end of it (IRPR s. 200(1)(b)). That ground has its own answer, covered below.
The officer’s notes in IRCC’s system (GCMS notes) explain what was missing or doubted. They decide which route is right, so they are the first thing a lawyer needs to see.
Why this refusal needs a lawyer
One lawyer, one file, every step:
- reading the refusal and the GCMS notes to see whether the problem is the occupation itself or the evidence;
- checking your spouse’s real duties against the National Occupational Classification;
- deciding, within days, between a rebuilt application (with restoration if needed) and judicial review;
- filing and arguing the judicial review in the Federal Court within the deadline.
Only a lawyer can represent you in the Federal Court. If the officer refused without dealing with an employer letter, an LMIA or a work permit that named an eligible occupation, that is a court argument, and the 15 days run from the refusal.
What are my options after a TEER refusal?
- Have a lawyer read the refusal and the GCMS notes. A job that is not on the list needs a different plan from a job that is on the list but was not proved.
- A new application with better evidence. If your spouse’s job is on the list, apply again with an employer letter that gives the NOC code, the TEER and the actual duties, plus pay stubs, the work permit and any LMIA. Answer the officer’s concern head on: if education was the issue, show how your spouse qualifies for the job (training, experience, a certificate or registration).
- Restoration, if the refusal ended your status in Canada. If you applied from inside Canada on maintained status, your status ended on the day of the refusal. Within 90 days you can apply to restore it together with a new open work permit application (IRPR s. 182).
- Judicial review in the Federal Court. Within 15 days of being notified (60 days if you are outside Canada; IRPA s. 72). If the Court finds the decision unreasonable, it sends the application back to a different officer.
- Reconsideration request. Discretionary, rarely changes the result, and does not stop the court deadline.
| Route | Time limit | What it can do | Fees (checked November 17, 2026) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Judicial review (Federal Court) | 15 days from notice in Canada; 60 days outside (IRPA s. 72) | Set the refusal aside and send it to a different officer | Court filing fee plus legal fees |
| Restoration + new open work permit | 90 days after losing status (IRPR s. 182) | A fresh decision on a rebuilt application; restores your status if approved | $246.25 restoration + $155 work permit + $100 open work permit holder fee = $501.25 |
| New application from inside Canada (status still valid) | Before your current status expires | A fresh decision on new evidence | $155 + $100 = $255 |
| New application from outside Canada | No deadline | A fresh decision on new evidence | $155 + $100 = $255 (plus a visitor visa, if you need one) |
| Reconsideration | None set; does not stop the court clock | Officer may reopen; rarely changes the result | None |
Which jobs qualify a spouse for an open work permit?
Since January 21, 2025, IRCC’s eligibility page (modified June 12, 2026) says the working spouse must be employed, or about to be employed, in:
- any TEER 0 or TEER 1 occupation; or
- one of the TEER 2 or TEER 3 occupations on IRCC’s list (mostly health care, natural and applied sciences, construction and the trades, natural resources, education and some transport jobs).
The worker’s permit must also be valid for at least 16 months after IRCC receives the spouse’s application, unless an exception applies. Workers who have applied for permanent residence through an eligible economic program are on a separate track, and BC’s significant investment projects have their own rule.
Common jobs: on the list or not?
| Job (NOC code) | TEER | Qualifies a spouse? |
|---|---|---|
| Licensed practical nurses (32101) | 2 | Yes (listed) |
| Early childhood educators and assistants (42202) | 2 | Yes (listed) |
| Automotive service technicians, truck and bus mechanics (72410) | 2 | Yes (listed) |
| Carpenters (72310) | 2 | Yes (listed) |
| Nurse aides, orderlies and patient service associates (33102) | 3 | Yes (listed) |
| Transport truck drivers (73300) | 3 | Yes (listed) |
| Retail sales supervisors (62010) | 2 | No (not listed) |
| Food service supervisors (62020) | 2 | No (not listed) |
| Cooks (63200) | 3 | No (not listed) |
| Administrative assistants (13110) | 3 | No (not listed) |
| Home support workers, caregivers (44101) | 4 | No (TEER 4) |
Check the code on IRCC’s page itself before you apply: the list is what the officer uses.
Refused because your spouse’s education doesn’t match the NOC?
This is the refusal people find hardest to understand. The working spouse has a job offer and a work permit for, say, a nurse aide position (NOC 33102, which is on the list), but studied something unrelated, such as marketing. The officer concludes that the spouse is not really working as a nurse aide.
The NOC describes the education an occupation usually needs; it is not a licence test. For NOC 33102, the NOC profile says “some secondary school education and on-the-job training” or a personal support worker, nursing aide or health care aide program, “and supervised practical training are required.” So a degree in another field does not, on its own, mean the job is something else. What matters is what your spouse actually does every day.
IRCC’s instructions tell officers they “can assess the TEER category of the principal foreign national using the NOC matrix” and list “a job contract, a letter from an employer indicating the NOC TEER category and duties” as the evidence. Build the new application around that:
- an employer letter listing the NOC code, the TEER and the duties in the employer’s own words, matched to the NOC’s main duties;
- proof of how your spouse qualifies for the job: the training, course or certificate, on-the-job training records, CPR and first aid, and any registration the employer requires;
- pay stubs, a T4 or ROE if available, and the work permit (and LMIA, if there was one) showing the same occupation.
If all of that was already in the file and the officer did not deal with it, the problem is the decision, not the evidence, and judicial review may be the stronger route.
Could the refusal be challenged in court?
Often, where the officer refused without engaging with documents that named an eligible occupation. In Sond v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 1397, the husband’s open work permit was refused because the officer could not “associate the pay slips with corresponding deposits” without bank statements, and found insufficient information about the wife’s “employment in a qualifying TEER.” The file had an employer letter stating her NOC and TEER, the LMIA confirmation, her work permit for that occupation and her pay stubs. The Federal Court found the decision unreasonable: the officer “needed to explain why they did not find the documents provided” persuasive, and why the absence of bank statements was fatal. The application went back to a different officer, with a chance to file more evidence.
The same decision dealt with money. The officer said the family lacked funds but did not address their savings, which together with the wife’s income exceeded the low-income figure the family relied on. The Court said officers must take a full look at the applicant’s funds, and an unexplained conclusion is not enough.
Judicial review looks only at what the officer had. If the job is not on the list, or the file never described the duties, a new application is usually the better route.
Restore in Canada, or reapply from outside?
This is the most common question after a refusal, and the answer depends on your status, not on processing times.
| Your situation | Usual route | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|
| In Canada; the refusal ended your maintained status | Restoration with a new open work permit application within 90 days | You can stay while restoration is pending but cannot work until a new permit is issued |
| In Canada with your own valid status (for example a visitor record or study permit) | New open work permit application from inside Canada | Keep that status valid; apply to extend it before it expires |
| Outside Canada, or planning to leave | New application from outside Canada | The officer also decides whether you will leave at the end of your stay, and many nationalities need a visitor visa to come back |
Leaving Canada to apply from abroad gives up any status or restoration rights you have here, and a visa refusal abroad leaves you outside. Decide with a lawyer before you book a flight.
Worked example: the dates
You are notified of the refusal on March 3. The 15-day judicial review deadline is March 18. If the refusal ended your maintained status, the 90-day restoration period runs to June 1. A reconsideration request sent on March 5 pauses neither.
What evidence answers a TEER refusal?
- The job: employer letter with the NOC code, TEER, duties, hours, wage and start date; the job contract.
- Proof it is real: pay stubs, T4 or ROE, and bank statements showing the deposits (not legally required, but they remove the question).
- Proof your spouse is qualified: training certificates, registration, on-the-job training records, reference letters from supervisors.
- The permit: the work permit, and the LMIA if there was one, showing the same occupation and at least 16 months of validity.
- Money: both spouses’ income, savings and the family’s costs in Canada, explained in a short letter.
- The relationship: marriage certificate or common-law declaration, and proof you will live together in Canada.
Mistakes I have seen
- I have seen employer letters that give a job title but no NOC code, no TEER and no duties.
- I have seen a job title that points to an eligible code (such as “supervisor”) on duties that fit a code that isn’t on the list.
- I have seen the same documents re-filed the week after a refusal, with nothing added about the officer’s concern.
- I have seen families leave Canada to apply from abroad, then wait outside the country because the visitor visa was refused.
- I have seen reconsideration requests sent while the 15-day court deadline ran out.
Frequently asked questions
Does IRCC check the working spouse’s education?
Not as a separate requirement. The test is whether the job is in an eligible occupation. Education becomes an issue when it makes the officer doubt that your spouse really does the work of the occupation the employer named.
My spouse’s closed work permit names an eligible NOC. Isn’t that enough?
It is strong evidence, and an officer who ignores it without explanation may have made a reviewable error. But the application should still include an employer letter with the duties and recent pay stubs.
My spouse changed jobs. Can we apply again?
Yes. If the new job is in an eligible occupation and the permit allows that work, apply with the new employer’s letter. Make sure the work permit still has at least 16 months left when IRCC receives your application.
Can I keep working after the refusal?
No, if you were working on maintained status. That status ended with the refusal, and you must stop working until a new permit is issued.
Will this refusal hurt a later visitor visa or PR application?
You must disclose it on every later application. A refusal on eligibility grounds is not a finding against your honesty, but leaving it out can be.
Is our case the same as a general spousal open work permit refusal?
This guide is about refusals over the job’s TEER or occupation. For refusals over missing employment proof, permit validity or a student spouse, see our main guide on a spousal open work permit refused.
What should I do right now?
Write down the date you were notified of the refusal. Gather the refusal letter, the GCMS notes if you have them, your spouse’s employer letter, pay stubs, work permit and LMIA. If you were working on maintained status, stop working and count your 90 days. Fifteen days passes fast.
Book a consultation with our immigration lawyers in Surrey, Abbotsford or Vancouver, or online from anywhere in Canada.
Ready to book? Open the booking form ↑
Sources (official)
- IRCC: Open work permits for family members of foreign workers: who can apply (modified June 12, 2026)
- IRCC program delivery instructions: family members of workers (C41/C46)
- NOC 2021: 33102 Nurse aides, orderlies and patient service associates
- IRPR s. 205, s. 200, s. 182 and s. 183
- IRPA s. 72
- IRCC fee list
- Sond v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 1397
This article is general information, not legal advice. Every case depends on its own facts.